Cincinnati Reds vs Cleveland Guardians Picks and Predictions

Cincinnati Reds vs Cleveland Guardians Best Betting Picks

Cincinnati Reds
Line: +140 Total: o8.5 Score: 0

Cleveland Guardians
Line: -170 Total: u8.5 Score: 0

Make your bets before 1:40pm EST 5/17/2026

Best Bets for the Cincinnati Reds vs Cleveland Guardians

Below are the top 5 sports handicappers with picks on this game. Experts are listed in order based based on their hit rate from previous picks on the Cincinnati Reds and/or Cleveland Guardians games and their overall MLB rankings. Visit their website directly to purchase their best bets for the day.

Rank	Sports Handicapper	30 Day MLB Record	MLB Season Record	Hit Rate	Website
#1	Harold Windham	53-41 (56%), +$4,790	94-63 (60%), +$15,405	100%	View Website
#2	Vic Diamante	49-37 (57%), +$4,685	88-59 (60%), +$11,535	100%	View Website
#3	Rich Roth	58-36 (62%), +$9,730	92-54 (63%), +$17,405	88%	View Website
#4	Kit Wilson	79-50 (61%), +$12,510	122-76 (62%), +$20,660	83%	View Website
#5	Cash Hoffman	59-42 (58%), +$7,510	105-60 (64%), +$22,205	83%	View Website

Vegas Trends and Betting Odds

Cincinnati Reds have won the past 2 out of 5 games while the Cleveland Guardians have won the past 4 out of 5 games. The Cincinnati Reds are 1 and 4 on the most recent away games while the Cleveland Guardians are 4 and 1 at home. Vegas has the line at Cleveland Guardians -170 and the total at 8.5.

More hot bets: Cleveland Cavaliers @ Detroit Pistons, New York Yankees @ New York Mets, or Toronto Blue Jays @ Detroit Tigers.