Best Sports Handicapping Services

We evaluated the 15 top sports handicapping services, anonymously, over the past 6 months and the three services listed below are our top picks based on winning consistency, website ease of use and customer service.

To be considered, all services must provide detailed records, display picks after the game start, and maintain positive reviews.


A "Web-3 sports handicapping platform" with thousands of bettors making picks daily, SportsJaw is the #1 predictions marketplace for every game in the NFL, NBA, NHL, MLB, NCAAF and NCAAB.

One thing we like about SportsJaw is the bet tracking and bankroll aspects of the handicapper picks. Also, you can follow picks from other professional bettors or you can make your own picks and track your bankroll this season. Of all of the services we reviewed, Sports Jaw has the most to offer with betting previews, analysis and the ability to sell your own picks.

Bottom Line: Great service, loads of features and priced realy well for guaranteed picks.

ATSExperts is a group of professional handicappers with a winning track record and decades of experience. Home to handicapping legends and founders Jack Pappano, Red Hansen and Peter Schoenke, ATS Experts has been a leading sports handicapping service for more than 20 years.

One thing we really like about ATSExperts is the usage of what they call the “hit rate”. This gives members the ability to quickly see which handicappers have historically performed the best on specific teams and gives the probability that they will hit this game.

Bottom Line: Solid service, easy pay options including "ATS Bucks" and guaranteed picks.
#3 has been recognized as a top online resource for expert sports picks and sports betting information since 2003. The handicappers tracked for Feburary 2024 verification included: Christopher Rockfeld, Mike Davis, Greg Michaels, and Patrick Adams.

The handicappers at Oddsboard provide picks daily, usually around midnight or early morning. If multiple handicappers have the same pick, it’s moved over to the “True Consensus”. The True Consensus did really well for all sports except NCAAF. Greg Michaels was the only handicapper we followed at Oddsboard who gave consistent college football wins.

Bottom Line: Daily Best Bets offers a credit back guarantee and weekly packages offer tremendus value.

*Note: This is a small sample of the best handicappers as of Feburary 2024. Services not included on this list may still be legitimate profitable sports handicappers. This list is based on our opinion and experience during this monitored window.

Factors Used to Rank the Best Handicappers

Profitability (Record + ROI)

You won’t see a Verified Cappers handicapping service featured on our rankings unless we are able to document all picks. Further all handicappers must demonstrate winning records and maintain positive reviews to be listed and ranked. We tracked the return on investment (ROI) for every service or handicapper, along with the record.

Value (Pricing Structure)

There are multiple pricing models used amongst the sports handicapping websites from weekly subscriptions to single picks pricing that ranges from $15 to $50 per pick with many recommended sites offering 100% money back guaranteed picks.

In most cases, sports prediction services will offer discounts for season/annual memberships.

Documented Records & Transparency

All services need to have verified documented results to earn a spot on our handicapper rankings. This means ALL PICKS must be released to the public after the start of the game and all records must be displayed and verified.

Reputation (Reviews)

All handicappers must maintain positive reviews and are further tracked via social media and other online channels to ensure positive reputations are maintained.

Customer Service

It’s important for handicapping services to be responsive and provide top shelf customer service. Our rankings are based on user feedback and personal experience from our staff regarding customer service. If we list a handicapping site in the top of our rankings, then you can know with certainty they provide excellent customer support. All of the services listed above had a response time of less than 12 hours and often times less than six hours depending on the time the support ticket was opened. We demand a high level of customer support in any service we recommend and you should too!

Looking for sports handicapper leaderboards? View our interactive top handicapper leaderboards to find the trending experts.